(black and white, 180 min, Italian)
Also known as Rocco e i suoi fratelli this film made Alain Delon a star and Luchino Visconti with La Terra Trema, Ossessione behind him, held promise as a film director to watch out for. He fulfilled that promise with some first rate works like The Leopard(1963), Senso (1954) and Death in Venice(1970) according to the order in quality. All the three are in color. As preface to Rocco and his brothers I shall merely mention that his films have a certain similarity in treatment. In Roger Egbert’s words’The experience of watching “Rocco and His Brothers” is rather overwhelming. So much happens, at such intensity and complexity, with such an outpouring of emotion, that we do feel we’re witnessing an opera.’ Yes it is operatic in the intensity of drama which is needed to tie up the several strands of the story as a whole by the emotional power of some scenes. It succeeds and the success of the film has to be judged by its effect on the viewer.
Luchino Visconti’s saga centers around Rosario an impoverished widow and her five children. At the beginning she is arriving at the station in Milan, the industrial hub of the northern Italy. The fifth son, Vincenzo, has already established himself there but has failed to meet them at the station. The family starts their life in Milan on inauspicious circumstances and we are given a run through of the contrast in their nature. Simon is sluggard and would rather stay in bed while the brothers raring to find work because of snow fallen overnight. Country bumpkins they are they are amused there is work to be had in cleaning up the streets. Back in their village snow would have melted without anybody’s notice.
Rocco is silent and almost a sleepy head still living in the coziness of his past. The unsinkable matriarch Rosaria (the great Greek actress Katina Paxinou) keeps tight control of the boys urging them to go out and achieve their place in the sun. She mothers them and also plays up to them according to their usefulness to the family and family pride to let the neighbors know their achievements however small. Each of these brothers represents a type — upright Ciro (Max Cartier), naïve Simone, self-sacrificing Rocco (Alain Delon), etc. — but Visconti, whose extensive experience as a stage director may have made him more than usually sensitive to actors, elicits superbly gritty performances, guiding them out of the stereotype into full-bodied characterizations.
Simone becomes a successful boxer but also a drunk, a thief, and a rapist. Ciro gets steady work in a car factory, to the joy of Rosaria and the disgust of Simone. To his mother’s horror, Simone takes up with a whore, Nadia (Annie Girardot), who falls in love with Rocco, widening the rift between the devoted brothers. And so it goes, toward the inevitable tragedy.
It is Simone who turns bad, filled with low self-esteem, proud of his wins but negligent of his training — smoking and drinking too much, and finally losing both Nadia and his boxing career.
Rocco steps in behind him, starting a liaison with Nadia and also a successful boxing career (which he doesn’t even want). But when Simone explodes with grief and jealousy (truly operatic, these scenes), there is a disgusting scene where Nadia is humiliated before the saintly Rocco who is helpless and in shock. He astonishingly breaks with Nadia, telling her she must return to his brother because, “He has only you.” In his eyes it is not his physical need but the cohesiveness of the family is uppermost. In a tearful melodramatic scene Nadia brilliantly emotes the heartbreak of being humiliated to the core.
When Simone finally goes berserk and kills her it is as operatic as Madama Butterfly resotres her honor after being jilted. The rape scene as well as the murder scene, aroused the wrath of the Italian censors, who had great difficulties with the film and its seamy portrait of life.
Annie Girardot’s prostitute Nadia also shows Visconti’s refusal to sugarcoat his vision. Her spiral from charismatic and self-assured cynic to bitter victim, ruined as much by the boys’ unnatural devotion to each other as by the exigencies of her lifestyle, is a cinematic highlight that makes the film unforgettable.
The film is structured on series of contrasts that is brought out in many ways. It is north versus south of which Milan the Industrial city is of the foreground and Lucania, kind of lost paradise which, as often the case is, lives only in memory. In the episodic nature of following the lives of five brothers we see how their individual characters unformed before they arrive and undergo changes as an indictment of the corruptive influence of citylife on the plasticine character. Low key lighting also underscore drab conditions contrasted with their affluence at the latter part.
Visconti’s La Terra Trema (1948) established his credentials as a director and here we see a mature work that can be ranked a masterpiece in the genre.Queer Marxist-aristocrat Visconti had enormous problems with Italy’s homophobic, reality-phobic government and church. The powers-that-be weren’t exactly thrilled that Rocco was unabashedly documenting the desperate shift in population from south, with its crushing poverty, to the north, which was threatening to sink under the weight of all those emigrants. Visconti was denied promised permits, forced to shoot in unsuitable locations, and humiliated when deep cuts were made and other scenes in this visually arresting film were darkened to obscure the action. And it couldn’t have pleased the director that Rocco‘s troubles were credited with inspiring authorities to attack Fellini’sLa Dolce Vita and Antonioni’s L’Avventura
The film is shot in carefully composed black and white that foregrounds the brothers and Nadia in many shots, showing them listening or reacting to what is happening behind them. ”Rocco and His Brothers” can be seen quite clearly, at this point, as an enormous influence on great American gangster films. Aspects of the Godfather immediately come into mind. And the critic D.K. Holm observes: “The tense, penitent relationship between Charlie( Harvey Keitel) and Johnny Boy(Di Niro) in Martin Scorsese’s ‘Mean Streets’ is almost unimaginable without the precedence of ‘Rocco and His Brothers.’ ” At a very subtle level, the love between the brothers seems too close for comfort. Unhealthy bond to keep the fraternity from breaking or finding their own ways in life must seem so. Even when towards the end where Simone confesses to Rocco of murder Ciro is for reporting to the police while Rocco fights with Ciro and vows to defend him.
There’s a great passage near the end, when Rocco has a great triumph on the same night when Simone ruins himself. Two fights, in a sense, are intercut. The neighbors pour out on to the balconies to cheer Rocco as a new champion, and then Simone comes home in wretched defeat to the always forgiving arms of his mother. The way the two story strands come together’ is manipulative, yes, but deeply effective’ (Egbert).
Of course Nino Rota’s them music as always gives the necessary pathos to the five brothers growing up in an alien environment.
benny